An analysis of a cloning argument in the modern society

Prospect of a New Eugenics For some of us, cloning-to-produce-children also raises concerns about the prospect of eugenics or, more modestly, about genetic "enhancement. CC looks different because she was made from a somatic cell from Rainbow in which the X-chromosome with the orange gene had been inactivated; only the black gene was active.

Find out more about Stem Cells.

An analysis of a cloning argument in the modern society

It is rather an enduring moral concern that might not be surmountable and should thus preclude work toward the development of cloning techniques to produce children. The end served by IVF is still the same as natural reproduction-the birth of a child from the union of gametes from two progenitors.

The initial suspicion—that television takes up only arguments against cloning and systematically ignores others—could not be confirmed after our analysis of the chosen documentaries.

Cloning is a human activity affecting not only those who are cloned or those who are clones, but also the entire society that allows or supports such activity.

The usually clear designations of father and brother, mother and sister, would be confounded. In some cases, these limitations can be disconcerting for the prospective parents or other family members, including existing children.

Issue Analysis: Human cloning

First, many people who are repelled by or opposed to the prospect of cloning human beings are concerned not simply or primarily because the procedure is unsafe. Conclusion Cloning-to-produce-children may represent a forerunner of what will be a growing number of capacities to intervene in and alter the human genetic endowment.

And it would represent a social experiment for the entire society, insofar as the society accepted, even if only as a minority practice, this unprecedented and novel mode of producing our offspring.

Yet, although cloning does not in itself point to public policies by which the state would become involved in directing the development of the human gene pool, this might happen in illiberal regimes, like China, where the government already regulates procreation.

In both cases, we place limits on the possible genetic outcome of the offspring, but in neither case is it clear whether or precisely how these limitations have an impact on its autonomy.

As a subject of everyday conversation, cloning is frequently related to eugenics, to the loss of human individuality and to blasphemy. Given that anyone considering creating a cloned child must know that he or she is putting a newly created human life at exceptional risk, the burden on the would-be cloners seems clear: Further, this argument appropriates the phrase "genetically related" to embrace a condition that has never before occurred in human history, one which abolishes the genetic variations that have always existed between parent and child.

A further glance at how this threat is presented is particularly informative. Keeping in mind our general observations about procreation, we proceed to examine a series of specific ethical issues and objections to cloning human children: In every case of cloning-to-produce-children, scientists or parents would set out to produce specific individuals for particular reasons.

An analysis of a cloning argument in the modern society

But the issue is not so simple. They are neither enabling nor restoring a natural process, and the alterations involved are such that success in one species cannot be presumed to predict success in another. Cloning is a human activity affecting not only those who are cloned or those who are clones, but also the entire society that allows or supports such activity.

However, the motives for duplicative cloning are usually on the basis of gross misconceptions about cloning, which abound in films, television programmes—including those that claim to be news programmes—and science-fiction novels Maio, In addition, animal studies have shown that many pregnancies involving cloned fetuses result in serious complications, including toxemia and excessive fluid accumulation in the uterus, both of which pose risks to the pregnant animal's health.

Although I find it mysterious that genetic connections are so highly prized—often more than social relationships among individuals—there is no denying the importance accorded to genetic ties.Arguments Against Reproductive Cloning.

1. Reproductive cloning would foster an understanding of children, and of people in general, as objects that can be designed and manufactured to possess specific characteristics.

Never let me clone?: Countering an ethical argument against the reproductive cloning of humans

2. Reproductive cloning would diminish the sense of uniqueness of an individual. The ethics of cloning and have concerns about how cloned individuals could integrate with families and with society at large Modern cloning vectors include selectable ethical arguments against human cloning would be thing for the person originated this way and for society The great cloning debate The last argument.

Brigitte Nerlich (and others) published: Anatomy of a Media. Human cloning proposes many arguments for each opposing side and can greatly impact the modern world based upon the research obtained through it. Whether or not that research is morally and ethically correct is the topic of most discussions in the genetics field.

Cloning in the media and popular culture

Countering an ethical argument against the reproductive cloning of humans Yvette Pearson 1 (Author photo) 1 Yvette Pearson is Co-Director of the Institute for Ethics and Public Affairs in the Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies, Old Dominion University, Norfolk, VA, USA.

Although the analysis draws on German films, its conclusions apply to other countries and societies—many of the metaphors for, and arguments against, cloning are used elsewhere in the world and often form the basis for popular mainstream films (Table 3).

Life science journals. Atomic John A an analysis of a cloning argument in the modern society truck driver uncovers secrets about the first nuclear bombs Over the summer. President George W Bush spoke of the W firmie moe si zmieni wszystko siedziba.

Download
An analysis of a cloning argument in the modern society
Rated 4/5 based on 83 review